0000359: Anonymous rating links hit by search engines

(0000874)
chrisaga (developer)
2006.04.27 20:03

<:o))

(0000875)
plg (manager)
2006.04.27 20:06

(I don't like Javascript very much.) Wouldn't it be a solution to have a form with N checkboxes and a submit "Rate" button?

(0000879)
rvelices (developer)
2006.04.27 22:36

I'll figure out something that works nice with JS (select with no button) and is also working without JS (select with Rate button)

(0000881)
plg (manager)
2006.04.27 23:02

rvelices, do you really like select box without submit button? I personnaly don't :-/ This is not accessible. I sometimes goes from field to field in a form with the tab key, and I really hate when it submits magicaly only because I passed on the "auto submit" select box.

When we have very few options and that option labels are short (like for rating), isn't it better to use checkbox/radio instead of select?

(0000887)
rvelices (developer)
2006.04.28 00:39

>I really hate when it submits magicaly
Personally I like it. Why do 2 clicks when you can do one?
But I'll do it your way (with radios because checkboxes cannot be mutually exclusive).
As at any given time, one radio must be selected, what whould be the default when the user didn't rate the picture yet ? Middle element of the array ?

(0000888)
rvelices (developer)
2006.04.28 04:18

Or maybe event better: a small form with five buttons ! That's one click and no Javascript

(0000891)
plg (manager)
2006.04.28 10:10

rvelices wrote:

> Or maybe event better: a small form with five buttons !

great :-)

Issue History
Date Modified	Username	Field	Change
2006.04.27 19:12	rvelices	New Issue
2006.04.27 19:12	rvelices	browser	=> any
2006.04.27 19:12	rvelices	Web server	=> Apache 1.3.x
2006.04.27 20:03	chrisaga	Note Added: 0000874
2006.04.27 20:06	plg	Note Added: 0000875
2006.04.27 22:36	rvelices	Note Added: 0000879
2006.04.27 23:02	plg	Note Added: 0000881
2006.04.28 00:39	rvelices	Note Added: 0000887
2006.04.28 04:18	rvelices	Note Added: 0000888
2006.04.28 04:18	rvelices	Assigned To	=> rvelices
2006.04.28 04:18	rvelices	Status	new => assigned
2006.04.28 10:10	plg	Note Added: 0000891
2006.04.29 18:14	rvelices	Status	assigned => closed
2006.04.29 18:14	rvelices	Resolution	open => fixed
2006.04.29 18:14	rvelices	Fixed in Version	=> 1.6.0RC2

Notes
(0000874) chrisaga (developer) 2006.04.27 20:03	<:o))

(0000875) plg (manager) 2006.04.27 20:06	(I don't like Javascript very much.) Wouldn't it be a solution to have a form with N checkboxes and a submit "Rate" button?

(0000879) rvelices (developer) 2006.04.27 22:36	I'll figure out something that works nice with JS (select with no button) and is also working without JS (select with Rate button)

(0000881) plg (manager) 2006.04.27 23:02	rvelices, do you really like select box without submit button? I personnaly don't :-/ This is not accessible. I sometimes goes from field to field in a form with the tab key, and I really hate when it submits magicaly only because I passed on the "auto submit" select box. When we have very few options and that option labels are short (like for rating), isn't it better to use checkbox/radio instead of select?

(0000887) rvelices (developer) 2006.04.28 00:39	>I really hate when it submits magicaly Personally I like it. Why do 2 clicks when you can do one? But I'll do it your way (with radios because checkboxes cannot be mutually exclusive). As at any given time, one radio must be selected, what whould be the default when the user didn't rate the picture yet ? Middle element of the array ?

(0000888) rvelices (developer) 2006.04.28 04:18	Or maybe event better: a small form with five buttons ! That's one click and no Javascript

(0000891) plg (manager) 2006.04.28 10:10	rvelices wrote: > Or maybe event better: a small form with five buttons ! great :-)

Relationships